August 2010 Archives

Nama Accounting Methods

| No TrackBacks

I wish to draw attention to Nama's accounting policies which have attracted little comment but have huge significance for taxpayers as the cost of the banking bale-out rises.

Specifically, Nama has decided to use a methodology which allows it to immediately write off about €40 billion of the €81 billion of loans being purchased from the banks and to ignore related interest, amounting to about €10 billion. This means that, with a stroke of the pen, Nama is forgiving about €50 billion of developer debts and, of course, making it much easier to report an illusionary "profit" when wound up.

Where is the "moral hazard" and justice in this when, based on Nama's creative accounting, every billion euro of discount on the loans being acquired is effectively a billion less to be paid by developers but a billion more to be pumped into the banks (mainly by taxpayers)? Suggestions by Nama that it will pursue debts to the "greatest possible extent" should be taken with a pinch of salt. As they don't even appear in Nama's balance sheet, where is the pressure to collect them?

Nama should be obliged to show the original value of the loans being acquired in its balance sheet and to properly account to taxpayers for bale outs and write offs when all methods of recovery have been exhausted.

Letter published in the Sunday Business Post on 22nd August 2010. For more on this topic, see this Open Letter to Nama's Board and the related blog entry.

Clearly the Minister for Finance's left hand does not know what his right hand is doing. 

On the one hand, he has the National Pension Reserve Fund with €17 billion invested in about 2,900 companies worldwide in addition to €7 billion invested, on his instructions, in the two main banks. Financed mainly by Exchequer borrowings, the Fund has produced a meagre 2.6% annual return since 2001. It now proposes to tilt its portfolio towards riskier investments in the hope of doubling its annual return so as outperform the cost of government debt, currently 5%.

On the other hand, the Minister is investigating the possibility of selling prime State assets to reduce the national debt. Such sales could occur at a low point in the economic cycle and would have to be "priced to go" to deliver profits to investors.

If the Minister joins his hands together, he could direct the Fund to dispose of its overseas investments and lend the proceeds to the Exchequer to generate a risk-free return for the Fund that matches the State's cost of borrowing. Alternatively, the proceeds could be used to make arms-length purchases of suitable State assets or invested in new infrastructural projects in Ireland.

Letter published in the Sunday Business Post on 8th August 2010.

Monthly Archives

Powered by Movable Type 4.38

About this Archive

This page is an archive of entries from August 2010 listed from newest to oldest.

July 2010 is the previous archive.

September 2010 is the next archive.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.